When I first saw Catrice‘s new shade I’m A Star it immediately reminded me of another polish by Catrice that was part of a LE called Papagena. Gejba reviewed and swatched all the polishes from that collection HERE. And I’m A Star reminded me of a polish called Welcome To The Jungle. Here are the comparison photos.
![Catrice - I'm A Star vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Papagena LE) Comparison: Catrice - I'm A Star vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Papagena LE)](https://www.parokeets.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/Catrice-Im_A_Star-vs-Welcome_To_The_Jungle-Parokeets-1B-450x341.jpg)
![Catrice - I'm A Star vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Papagena LE) Comparison: Catrice - I'm A Star vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Papagena LE)](https://www.parokeets.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/Catrice-Im_A_Star-vs-Welcome_To_The_Jungle-Parokeets-2B.jpg)
As you can see from the photos above, these are not dupes. Welcome To The Jungle is deeper and richer in color. The application of both was unproblematic. I love both, but if I had to choose Welcome To The Jungle would be the winner for me.
And which one do you prefer? I’m A Star or Welcome To The Jungle?
This post is also available in SLOVENŠČINA.
I’d prefer Welcome to the Jungle but since I didn’t find it I’m glad there is such a similar shade in the regular line!
Both polishes are really great but if I had to choose Welcome to the Jungle would be my pick. I like the deeper color and the name is really awesome too! :D
I have Welcome To The Jungle , so I think is silly to buy the other one :wink:
Imam Welcome To The Jungle in ne bom kupila I’m A Star, sta praktično identična. Pa WTTJ nosi ime po kul komadu, tako da je zmagovalec. :thumb: :wink:
they’re definatly not dupes, but not worth having both either (for me at least :P )
i have welcome to the jungle, for me also the best one from these two.
I already have bought the LE from the Papagena collection, and saw I’m a star on the shelves, and decided not to buy it because I thought they looked similiar… And now you’ve proven it :)
I prefer Welcome To The Jungle because it has slightly more shimmer in it :)
I agree with you: they are not dupes but this is a pity, because welcome to the jungle is better and LE. I own it, but what a pity for who doesn’t ç___ç
I love them both! :)
I have Welcome to the Jungle and is gorgeous indeed. I did notice this ‘suppose’ dupe in the store but knew WTTJ would be better.
Thx for the comparison. :rose:
I didn’t get I’m A Star as they had only one bottle and my swap partner needs it more. :silly: After seeing your comparison, I’m not sure I’ll get it at all. :biggrin:
Sicer neka razlka res je, ampak bolje kot nič je že :)
Zdaj pa naj samo še ustvarijo en lak, ki bo enak Enter the Undergrowth pa bom happy :D
honestly they really look the same to me. lol. they look good on you. I’m not sure i’d buy it. i like greens.. but i don’t know if this will look good on me.
I agree.. Although the diference is not big, I would go for Welcome to the Jungle.